Scarlet Self-Titled Review

November 8, 2026
The cover of a game called the renfields

Scarlet

Self-Titled

FNA Records

2010


Today we’re digging WAY back into the FNA catalog with Scarlet’s self-titled release from 2010. Unfortunately, this is one of those label releases that I find myself having a hard time appreciating, but that has everything to do with what it is rather than how it sounds. Scarlet falls into the Christian Rock/Metal category, and I've never been particularly fond of this style or genre. It's not necessarily the music itself, but the lyrical content just doesn't do much for me. Oftentimes, I find it a little hokey. And no, I'm not some first-class Satanist or anything silly like that. I just don't care for the subject matter. Hell, I'm not even much of a Stryper fan! That said, I know plenty of my peers who absolutely loved this stuff back in the day and still do. So, we're going to give it some attention because my old-school homies deserve to know about this one!

 

Scarlet formed in Tampa in 1983 after the members met through a local youth group. It didn't take long for the band to get into the studio and start making some noise in the Florida music scene. They even submitted a track or two to MTV's Basement Tapes, eventually landing among the top four finalists. That's quite an accomplishment, particularly considering the band's musical and lyrical direction. No disrespect intended, of course!

 

As I understand it, this disc brings together Scarlet's complete recorded output, spanning several different lineups. The band went through a few personnel changes along the way, including different drummers and guitarists, so there's naturally a bit of variety in the overall sound. Still, everything fits comfortably within the framework of those analog recording techniques that defined the early to mid-'80s. The music follows suit, with some material leaning toward straight-up Hard Rock while other moments venture into heavier territory, flirting with traditional Heavy Metal. There are some genuinely nice melodies, memorable riffs, and plenty of tasty guitar leads scattered throughout.

 

For an old-school Rock Warrior like me, there's plenty to appreciate here, provided I can get past the lyrical content. Musically, Scarlet checks most of the boxes, although I'd be lying if I said the vocals hit the mark every time. I can easily see this one finding a welcome home in the collections of plenty of Rock and Metal fans, particularly those who grew up embracing the Christian Rock/Metal scene. And that's precisely why I wanted to give it some attention. There aren't a whole lot of bands flying that flag anymore, and while it's never been my cup of tea, I recognize that there's an audience for it. FNA Records still has copies readily available, so if you're a follower of Christianity who enjoys your Rock and Metal with a little faith mixed in, this one is certainly worth checking out.

share this